Deadliest Warrior:
Rick Grimes vs. The Man
Since The Road held so many similarities to AMC's The Walking Dead, I figured I'd explore this question: Who would win in a fight - Rick Grimes from The Walking Dead, or the Man from The Road? Read below to find out in the series finale of The Road blog posts.
Who has the edge?
Since both these stories are about survival, how could each of them fare on their own? Rick has barely been alone during the series, as most of the time he is seen leading the Group. However, in the beginning of Season 6 (the current season), he becomes separated from those protecting Alexandria, and he has no vehicle in which to return. He must therefore sprint all the way back to the town while avoiding walkers, and surviving an attack from the Wolves. While his performance then was impressive, Rick has really yet to be alone in the wilderness. In Season 5, the Group walked a long distance along a road much like the Man and the Boy, but Rick relied more on the insight of his group members. A good example is when Daryl finds a barn that the Group stays in during a thunder storm. He also usually sends other group members on supply runs, as opposed to going himself. Rick is terrific at surviving, but more so against live (or undead) forces that are out to kill him, as opposed to the forces of nature.
The Man, on the other hand, is very crafty when it comes to survival. It's downright impressive that he and his son survive for as long as they do with just a cart to carry supplies. Not to mention, they have to hide the cart to avoid being spotted when others come along the road. The Man is able to locate a flare gun on a boat because he has the necessary prior knowledge, and he also is able to use that flare gun as a weapon to survive. The Man is also alone much more often than Rick is. Many times, the Man travels by himself during the night to either get supplies or scout ahead. Additionally, the Man is able to obtain the materials that he and his son need through carefully planned supply raids of homes and shelters.
Clearly, the Man is better able to survive on his own than Rick Grimes. The edge goes to the Man.
Both of these men are the leaders of their groups, but which one is the better leader? Rick leads a very large group, and despite all the deaths that occur, currently the Group is increasing in size. Also, the amount of deaths that happen under Rick's command is alarming. However, Rick has kept most of his group alive for six seasons, and he himself has survived that long as well. He's helped them survive many threats such as Shane, the Governor, members of Terminus, and most recently, the Wolves, not to mention all of the walkers that occupy the world. That's an impressive accomplishment. Rick's weakness is in his mental health, which fluctuates throughout the show. After being forced to kill his best friend in season two's finale, he declares his group a dictatorship run by himself. Following the death of his wife, Laurie, he begins to hallucinate, seeing images of her in broad daylight. It drives him mad, and nearly costs the lives of his group members as his series of breakdowns happen in the middle of the conflict with the Governor. In Season 5, after being crossed for the last time by those at Terminus, he completely loses his morals, and Machonne, one of his most trusted group members, even turns on him. And in the current season, Rick has declared that he doesn't take chances anymore, which could have major consequences down the road.
The Man has a single member in his group, the Boy. Throughout their travels, he teaches his son how to be a better survivor. He must overcome challenges such as the "bad guys," who are cannibals with absolutely no morals, as they even eat human infants. The Man also feels he must kill his own son as opposed to letting him try to survive on his own. The Man ultimately dies of illness, leaving his only group member alone in the horrific world they live in. Often times, he leaves the Boy behind, which could leave both himself and the boy vulnerable to attack. He also loses his morals at one point when he forces the thief to take off all of his clothes and give them up to pay for what he had done, something that most likely killed him. One of the most impressive accomplishments of the Man as a leader was when he lead the boy through pitch darkness along the beach to retrieve the pistol, then walk all the way back to the tarp where they started. Since they could hardly see, the Man relied on brief lightening strikes for light, which only lasted a fraction of a second. Ultimately, the Man heard the rain hitting the tarp, and they were able to return successfully to their supplies. Well done.
While Rick's group has lost many members, and the Man's group has lost none (other than himself), one would think this would be an easy edge for the Man. However, Rick is responsible for a much larger group that deals with many more threats than the characters in The Road do. Also, even though the Man is able to maintain his morals for the most part and continues to "carry the fire," Rick's lapse in mental health and loss of morals is understandable due to all the stress he was under. Rick has to deal with worse conditions than the Man and the Boy do, and the fact that he has overcome those lapses and is still alive and leading his group today shows his strength as a character and as a good leader. The edge goes to Rick Grimes.
Result:
A draw.
The Scenario:
As Rick is running back to Alexandria to defend against the herd of Walkers, he encounters the Man and the boy walking along the road. Having just been attacked and wounded by the Wolves, Rick assumes the Man is of the same group, and immediately gets out his pistol and aims it at the Man. The boy hides behind him. The Man sees Rick and immediately counters him with his flare gun. At a standstill, they both begin to talk.
A flare gun, interesting choice, Rick says.
A direct hit will light you up, so I suggest you drop the gun, the Man counters.
Well I don't take chances anymore.
Rick cocks the gun.
I'm warning you, the Man says.
Suddenly, a walker sneaks up behind Rick, forcing him to turn around to defend himself. The Man sees his chance to get away as more walkers begin to surround the injured Rick, and he grabs the boy by the arm and begins to escape.
But Papa, says the boy, he'll die.
He was going to hurt us. He was going to hurt you.
We cant leave him here to die.
He can survive on his own.
The boy begins to cry.
But Papa, you said you wouldnt do this anymore. Remember what happened with the thief.
Upon hearing this, the Man stops, and turns back toward Rick, who struggles to fight off the walkers.
He's out of bullets Papa, sobs the boy.
The Man then runs over to Rick and begins to help him fight the walkers. The Man finds and uses stones for projectiles, and tree limbs from the ground as spears. But the walkers are too many, and as a group they are too strong. Rick, seeing this, tells the Man to use the flare gun.
The fire will spread quickly, you'll take out most of them, Rick shouts.
The Man aims the weapon, and pulls the trigger. Rick, to the Man's surprise, was right. The affected walker stumbles back, on fire, and hits another walker, lighting it on fire as well, starting a chain reaction.
Rick, having found two potential allies, turns to the Man and the boy.
The fire will only attract more, Rick says. We have to leave now. Leave the cart behind.
The boy looks up at the Man. They both remain standing still.
Come on, we gotta go now! Rick yells to the two of them as he begins to sprint away. They follow him.
How many walkers have you killed? Rick asks as they run.
I don't know, too many, replies the Man.
How many people have you killed?
One... perhaps two.
Why?
They were threatening my son and me. They were going to eat us alive, I had no choice.
Rick continues to run, thinking about whether to add them to the Group.
What would you have done if you were in that situation? The Man asks.
I would have killed them. I did kill them. I faced them before, at Terminus.
They run a bit farther along the road.
My group is under attack by walkers, says Rick. They aren't far from here.
The Man looks down at the boy, who begins to stumble behind.
We could use your help, Rick continues. There's shelter there too, and food. You'll survive there.
We need to help them, Papa, says the boy.
We can't, the Man replies.
But Papa! We have to carry the fire, remember? You, yourself, said that. We have to help them!
The Man sighs, looks up at Rick, and nods.
Alright, we'll help you and your friends, the Man says. By the way, you got a name?
Rick Grimes, he responds. What's yours?
End Scenario